New Mexico Roofing Company Case Study
From Shared Leads to 70+ Inbound Leads a Month
This New Mexico roofing company was doing what a lot of roofers do. It relied on shared third-party leads and Local Services Ads, then raced several other contractors to reach the same homeowner first.
Over six months, FMS Online Marketing helped the company build visibility it owns across Google Search, Google Maps and AI-powered search, so more homeowners found it and reached out directly.
Here’s what was holding the company back, what we changed, and what happened between April 1 and October 1, 2026.
Results at a Glance
Six months of work, from April 1 to October 1, 2026.
+125%
Organic website traffic
30 → 70+
Monthly inbound leads
1–2 → 3–5
Roof installations closed per week
~30%
Profit growth, after expenses
The Challenge: Paying for Leads They Had to Share
Before working with FMS, most of this roofer’s new business came from shared third-party leads and Local Services Ads.
Both can produce calls. The problem is who else gets them. A shared lead often goes to several contractors at once, so the company was competing on speed and price for the same customers before the first conversation even started.
Two other problems made that cycle hard to break:
- Google Maps visibility dropped off fast. The company showed up for searchers close to its office, but its Maps visibility fell sharply outside a roughly three-mile radius. Homeowners in the rest of its service area were seeing competitors first.
- The website wasn’t ready for AI search. It lacked the structure and clear, answer-focused content that Google and AI tools like ChatGPT use to understand a business and decide who to recommend.
Want to see what an AI-search-ready roofing website looks like? Take a look at our Sunny State Roofing demo site, built in-house by FMS, or learn more about our SEO-ready websites.
Our Strategy: Build Visibility the Company Owns
Instead of buying more leads, FMS focused on expanding the company’s local visibility and strengthening its overall search foundation. The work included:
✔ Google Business Profile optimization
A complete, accurate profile so Google can match the company to more roofing searches.
✔ Citation cleanup and NAP consistency
The same business name, address and phone number everywhere the company is listed.
✔ Localized service signals
Making it clear which roofing services the company offers and where it offers them.
✔ Improved review strategy
A steady, consistent way to ask happy customers for reviews.
✔ Answer-focused website content
Clear answers to the questions homeowners ask before hiring a roofer.
✔ Schema markup
Structured data that spells out the business, its services and its service area for search engines.
✔ GEO optimization
Strengthening the information AI-powered search tools use to understand and recommend a business.
Each piece supports the others. A stronger profile, consistent listings and steady reviews were aimed at helping the company compete beyond the area right around its office. Better content and schema helped search engines and AI tools understand exactly what it does.
The Results: More Leads They Didn't Have to Share
From April 1 to October 1, 2026:
- Organic website traffic increased 125%.
- Monthly inbound leads grew from about 30 to more than 70.
- Closed roof installations grew from 1–2 a week to 3–5 a week.
- Profit grew about 30% after all expenses.
Inbound leads come straight to the company from homeowners who found it online, so it isn’t splitting them with other contractors.
As those calls grew, the company cut back on Local Services Ads by month four and has since stopped using them entirely. Spending less on paid leads while closing more jobs is a big part of that profit growth.
The results came from Local SEO, Google Business Profile optimization, consistent business information, a better review strategy and helpful website content working together.
What Other Roofing Companies Can Take From This
✔ Shared leads keep you racing on price. Visibility you build yourself brings calls you don’t have to split.
✔ Ranking near your office isn’t enough. Check how you show up across your whole service area, not just your own neighborhood.
✔ Consistent business info and steady reviews still matter. They’re part of how Google and AI tools decide who to trust.
✔ Answer the questions homeowners ask. It helps you show up in search results and in AI answers.
Every roofing market is different, and results depend on your competition, service area and starting point. If you want to know where your company stands, we’ll show you.
